A common way to describe people is by temperature. “They are very cold people”, “Everyone here
is so warm”. What does it take to be part of the cold group or the warm group?
Is one group better than the other? Why do people use this adjective like this?
I think many of us have heard certain nationalities
described as “cold”. However, I don’t think this is a racist expression, but
one which might show a lack of understanding and also a specific recognition
that a cultural difference exists between you and the person you are describing.
Throughout my life I have often heard “cold” refer to Russians or Eastern
Europeans and not knowing anything about Russian life or culture, I unknowingly
accepted this as a fitting description. Recently I have heard Chileans
describing Chinese people as cold. This labelling of Chinese people as cold
made me start to question the expression, its meaning and validity, as I,
having lived in and studied Chinese culture, would not describe them as cold.
People being labelled as “cold” could have something to do
with the climate of a certain country or region. From what I can tell Russia is
very cold in winter, pictures of Siberia spring to mind. Maybe people in colder
climates spend more time indoors with their families rather than outside with
others and this affects their ‘warmth’ or closeness with others when they see
them. However there are quite a few exceptions to this climate stereotype. For
example, I have never heard Canadians be described as cold, and I know they get
a fair amount of snow every year.
It could have something to do with your style of interaction
with other people. Introverted people can be described as cold because they
might not desire to communicate or to spend extended periods of time with other
people in “conventional” environments. Shy people too, people who don’t speak
that specific language well, people who are sick or tired and so remain
distant. In this way ‘cold’ is used to distance certain styles of interaction
while the more “mainstream” styles are interpreted as correct. Sometimes this
use of ‘cold’ is specific to individuals rather than a large group of people
which is interesting. The word cold can be used in both contexts without
question. Stereotyping is so vague that one word can describe an entire group
of people; millions of citizens, and these simple, one word descriptions,
images and perspectives all influence the way we view and interact with other
cultures.
It could also refer to physical interaction. Cold weather is
also said to be ‘frigid’, being unable to enjoy sexual contact. So extrapolating
from that, people who don’t touch or kiss as a natural social behaviour tend to
be described as cold. In this sense physical contact is interpreted as a
positive personality trait.
Maybe cold is a word that expresses a negative alternative
to ones cultural comfort zone. I’m thinking that generally people from ‘warm’,
touchy, louder cultures are the ones that use this word, ‘cold’, as a negative
adjective. Why not use the word ‘shy’ or ‘reserved’? Probably because people
are somewhat afraid of the unknown culture they are dealing with and so tend to
push it away with a type of insult.
For all we know touching and kissing (for greetings or
during a friendly conversation) could be a dangerous habit for spreading
infection. Talking a lot, asking a lot of questions and loudly, could be
disrespectful to a host or push boundaries of relationships in certain
cultures. Until you have put in the time to figure out a culture, you will
never know. If people studied other cultures they wouldn’t see the way people
act as strange and negative, they would just know that in that culture there
are different ways of expressing your mood and personality.
The words we use to describe others shed light on our own
cultures, personalities, perspectives and knowledge.
Portuguese people, or Southern Europeans, are known as "warm people". :P
ReplyDeleteAnyway, a very interesting post!
Thanks Rita, I would be interested to know your thoughts on why they are known as such :)
DeleteYour words and thoughts are very interesting. You also write very well. Keep up as I enjoy reading this blog. JV
ReplyDeleteCheers JV!
Delete